Welcome to Geological Journal of China Universities ! Today is
Share:

J4

• Article • Previous Articles     Next Articles

U/Th and U/Pa Dating of Nanjing Man

CHENG Hai1, R.Lawrence.Edwards1, WANG Yong-jin2   

  1. 1. Department of Geology & Geophysics, University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN55455, USA; 2. College of Geographical Sciences, Nanjing Normal Univ., Nanjing 210097, China
  • Received:2003-12-20 Revised:2003-12-20 Online:2003-12-20 Published:2003-12-20

Abstract: Evidence from China is crucial in order to understand hominid evolution,with age dating being critical to interpret the evidence. Homo erectus fossils, including two skulls and a tooth,were discovered interbedded with cave deposits in the suburbs of Nanjing in 1993 and 1994, and are referred to as“Nanjing Man”.U/Th ages of the calcite flowstone overlying the Nanjing Man fossils are 533+_15 12ka or 533+-35 30ka,if considered accurately.The[231Pa/235U] activity ratio of the flowstone is 0.998±0.006.indicating concordance of U/Th and U /Pa ages .A stratigraphically younger stalagmite gives an age progression consistent with the internal stratigraphy of the stalagmite:465+-45 35 ka;398±15 ka;350±10 ka;260±8 ka and 160±2 ka.Our data indicate that Nanjing Man is older than 500 ka.We analyzed five animal teeth from the Nanjing site by TIMS.U/Th ages vary from 185 to 290 ka and U/Pa ages from 137 to 172 ka.For both U/Th and U/Pa ages, the each age is less than that of the dentine for the same tooth.In addition,the U/Pa age of each tooth subsample is less than its U/Th age by 24~40% .Thus,these teeth do not follow an early uranium uptake mode1.In a[234U /238U]vs.[230Th/238U]diagram,the tooth data plot in a field between early U uptake(EU)and linear U uptake(LU) curves.This indicates a U uptake history between the EU and LU model,which has been the general consensus on uptake history for these types of samples.In this case, both U/Th and U/Pa LU model ages will be the upper limit of the samples .However,the U/Pa age may give a better estimation be cause it is not affected by the possible variation of input 234U/238U ratios.The minimum U/Pa LU model age is 1 Ma, which gives a constraint on the upper limit of Nanjing Man age.Although possible,it is not conclusive that Nanjing Man lives in marine 16O isotope stage 16(MIS16).